Wednesday, June 18, 2008, 09:53 AM CST [
General]
The Scoop: Ricki Lake responds to recent statements made by the AMA regarding her do****entary The Business of Being Born. From the AP:
Ricki Lake is firing back at physicians groups that have singled her out for bringing attention to at-home childbirth.
The 39-year-old former talk-show host is named in a recent statement by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists that says the home is not the safest setting for having a baby.
In her film "The Business of Being Born," a do****entary about the maternity care system that premiered at the Tribeca Film Festival, Lake is shown giving birth in the bathtub of her Manhattan apartment to her second son Owen, who turns 7 on Wednesday.
The ACOG statement, supported in a resolution Tuesday by the American Medical Association, said, "There has been much attention in the media by celebrities having home deliveries," citing a "Today Show" headline that read "Ricki Lake takes on the baby birthing industry: Actress and former talk show host shares her at-home delivery in her new film."
"It's scary that both (the ACOG and the AMA) have sort of targeted me," Lake told The Associated Press on Tuesday. "And, you know, I'm all about choice. This is not unlike the abortion issue. I am pro-choice when it comes to childbirth and choices in birth. Home birth was around long before hospitals were taking over _ and I just think women need to know (the information) so that they can make the best choice for them."
The AMA resolves in the statement to support state legislation "that helps ensure safe deliveries and healthy babies by acknowledging that the safest setting" is a hospital, connected birthing center or other approved facility.
"There's a lot of provocative things that are said in the film," she said, "but I think it's very clear that we need doctors, we need the care and the technology that we have. But we also need to value the process of giving birth normally."
Lake said she had no problems delivering her oldest son Milo, 11, at the hospital, but "looking back on it, I felt that I did not necessarily need the intervention. I didn't need the (drug Pitocin, which induces labor). I just should have labored on my own."
The second time around, as long as her pregnancy continued to be low-risk, she decided to give birth at home.
"I was empowered, I was transformed and I would love for women to have had that opportunity _ to be an active participant in their own birth choices and birth experience," she said.
(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)
Colleen says: Oh for goodness sake. People are so sensitive.
The AMA and the ACOG have every right to educate the public about the risks of home-birth. They have a vested interest in making sure that people do the medically sound thing - it's kind of their job. Ricki Lake has every right to make an informed decision that is counter to that based on her own beliefs. Case closed.
When I try to educate people about SIDS risk reduction (based on the fact that I am unfortunately an expert having graduated from the school of life) people argue with me believing that I am making a judgement. For example, the new recommendation by the American Academy of Pediatrics is that babies sleep in a space of their own. In other words, co-sleeping (where parents and children sleep together in an adult bed) has been linked to a higher rate of suffocation and entrapment in infants leading to death. I am only presenting the recommendation of the American Academy of Pediatrics (a bunch of folks who I trust, who study this type of thing). I always tell people that it's important to know this information and then to make your own decision taking into account both sides. Research has also shown co-sleeping does wonderful things for parent child bonding. See, no harm no foul. I made the decision not to co-sleep based on my life experience, another may make another decision. None of my business what they decide (that won't stop me from educating people on the front end though).
Informing about one aspect doesn't mean disapproving of the other. This is the mistake we make as parents. If someone says breast is best, we automatically assume that they believe that formula is evil. If someone says hospital birth is best, we automatically think they believe that home birth is irresponsible. I wish we could all get comfortable with the concept of "best for me and my family." I rehearse this line frequently, "we have made the decision ____ because it is what is best for our family." It is right to be so protective of our children and the decisions we make in parenting them. It's very important and personal work. I just wish that we could unite a little more and divide a little less. We're all in this together trying to figure out how to do it - and frankly, none of us has all the answers. The research is there to inform the rest is up to us.
I'll put my soapbox away now.